10 Myths About Roof Replacement You Need to Stop Believing

04/12/2025

Replacing your roof comes with a wave of uncertainty, misinformation, and hesitation. Many homeowners hem and haw over necessary roof work because they believe in outdated or completely WRONG information.

As a trusted roofing company in Brick, Fortified Roofing is here to set the record straight. Let’s debunk 10 common roofing myths that could cost you time, money, and peace of mind.

1. Myth: Roof Replacement Is Only Necessary When There’s a Leak

Truth

While roof leaks are a clear sign of trouble, it’s not the only reason to go the replacement route. Curling shingles, bald spots, sagging, and old age also indicate your roof needs attention. Waiting for a leak can lead to interior damage and mold growth.

2. Myth: A New Roof Can Be Installed Over the Old One

Truth

While some municipalities allow roof overlays, this shortcut isn’t always advisable. Layering shingles can hide damage, trap heat and moisture, and shorten the life of your new roof. It voids plenty of warranties too.

3. Myth: Roof Replacement Is a DIY Job

Truth

Roofing is dangerous and complex. Even experienced DIYers can make serious mistakes that can lead to leakage, poor insulation, and structural problems. ALWAYS rely on licensed professionals who understand building codes and safety protocols.

4. Myth: All Roofing Materials Are the Same

Truth

Roofing materials vary in cost, durability, and aesthetics. Asphalt shingles, metal, slate, and synthetics all serve different needs. The right material depends on your home, budget, and climate.

5. Myth: Roof Replacements Are Always Expensive

Truth

The cost of a roof replacement depends on many things such as size, pitch, materials, and labor. Fortified Roofing offers competitive pricing and financing options. Plus, a high quality roof increases your home’s value and reduces future repair costs!

6. Myth: Roofs Last Forever

Truth

Even the best roofs have an expiration date, so to speak. Asphalt shingles typically last 20 to 30 years, while metal and tile roofs can last longer. Routine maintenance can extend your roof’s life, but no material is immune to the passage of time!

7. Myth: You Can’t Replace a Roof in Winter

Truth

While winter weather can be tricky, many roofing companies – including Fortified Roofing – have the experience and equipment to perform safe and effective installations all year-round. Proper planning and product selection are key.

8. Myth: Roof Inspections Aren’t Necessary

Truth

Regular roof inspections can reveal hidden water damage, flashing issues, and wear that isn’t visible with the naked eye. They’re needed in extending roof life, so don’t sleep on setting up a regular schedule with your roofer!

9. Myth: Warranties Cover Everything

Truth

Not all warranties are created equal. Some cover materials only, others labor, and many have strict requirements like regular maintenance. Always review warranty details and work with a roofing company that stands behind its workmanship.

10. Myth: Roof Replacement Is a Cosmetic Upgrade

Truth

A new roof boosts curb appeal, but more importantly, it protects your home from weather, pests, and energy loss. It also affects insurance premiums and the resale value of homes.

Common Myths vs. Facts

Common Roofing Myths	Roofing Replacement Facts
Only leaks require replacement	Damage or age can also indicate the need for replacement
DIY is cheaper and just as effective	Mistakes can cost more long term; safety + expertise matters
All materials are the same	Material choice greatly affects lifespan and performance
Roofs last forever	ALL roofing materials have a limited lifespan
Warranties cover everything	Warranties vary and often require specific conditions

Fortified Roofing Can Help You Bust through the Myths

Roof replacement misconceptions can lead to errors and delays. Understanding the truth about roof replacement empowers you to make informed, safe, and lasting decisions for your home.